Differences Between DNA Prenatal Paternity Testing and Traditional Paternity Testing

What is DNA Prenatal Paternity Testing?

DNA Prenatal Paternity Testing (NIPPT) is a test that uses a sample of blood taken from the pregnant mother to extract fetal DNA and compare it with the DNA of a potential father to confirm paternity. This test can be performed after the 10th week of pregnancy and is notable for not posing any risk to the mother or fetus while verifying the parent-child relationship.

What is Traditional Paternity Testing?

Traditional paternity testing includes tests done after birth and invasive methods performed during pregnancy. After birth, paternity is confirmed by comparing the child’s DNA with the potential father’s DNA. Invasive prenatal paternity tests, such as amniocentesis and chorionic villus sampling (CVS), involve collecting fetal cells directly from the mother’s body to analyze DNA. These methods come with certain risks.

Differences in Methods Between DNA Prenatal Paternity Testing and Traditional Paternity Testing

The main difference between DNA Prenatal Paternity Testing and traditional paternity testing is in the testing methodology.

Methods of DNA Prenatal Paternity Testing

In DNA Prenatal Paternity Testing, fetal DNA present in small amounts in the mother’s blood is extracted and compared with the DNA of the potential father. This method is very safe because it only involves drawing blood from the mother. The use of advanced technologies like Next-Generation Sequencing (NGS) allows for highly accurate analysis of fetal DNA, making this method very reliable.

Methods of Traditional Paternity Testing

In traditional paternity testing, particularly the invasive methods performed during pregnancy, samples are collected directly from the fetus. Amniocentesis involves inserting a needle through the mother’s abdomen to collect amniotic fluid, while CVS involves taking a sample of placental tissue. These samples are used to extract fetal DNA and compare it with the potential father’s DNA.

Differences in Risks

Another important difference between DNA Prenatal Paternity Testing and traditional paternity testing is the risks associated with the test.

Risks of DNA Prenatal Paternity Testing

DNA Prenatal Paternity Testing is non-invasive and involves only drawing blood from the mother, which means it carries almost no risk of miscarriage or infection. The test itself is safe and places minimal burden on the pregnant woman.

Risks of Traditional Paternity Testing

Traditional paternity testing, especially invasive methods like amniocentesis and CVS, involves inserting needles to collect samples, which carries risks such as miscarriage and infection. The risk of miscarriage is approximately 0.5-1%, which can be a significant concern for pregnant women. These tests are conducted in medical facilities and require careful management by specialists.

Differences in Accuracy

DNA Prenatal Paternity Testing and traditional paternity tests also differ in terms of accuracy.

Accuracy of DNA Prenatal Paternity Testing

DNA Prenatal Paternity Testing is said to have over 99% accuracy in confirming paternity. The use of NGS technology allows for precise comparison of fetal and potential father’s DNA, providing highly reliable results. Additionally, being non-invasive contributes to its accuracy by minimizing potential complications.

Accuracy of Traditional Paternity Testing

Traditional paternity testing, particularly post-birth DNA tests, also boasts very high accuracy. Invasive methods performed during pregnancy are expected to be over 99% accurate, but there is a slight risk of incorrect results depending on the sample collection method. Difficulties in interpreting results can arise if samples are insufficient or if multiple fetuses are present.

Differences in Cost

There are also differences in the costs of DNA Prenatal Paternity Testing and traditional paternity tests.

Cost of DNA Prenatal Paternity Testing

DNA Prenatal Paternity Testing is a relatively new technology and can be expensive. In Japan, the cost generally ranges from 100,000 to 200,000 yen and is often not covered by insurance, meaning it is typically paid out-of-pocket. Despite the cost, many couples accept this expense due to the test’s safety and non-invasive nature.

Cost of Traditional Paternity Testing

Traditional paternity testing, particularly post-birth DNA tests, is generally less expensive than DNA Prenatal Paternity Testing. However, invasive prenatal tests can be costly due to their complexity and associated risks. These tests are also often not covered by insurance, so it’s important to confirm costs in advance.

Timing of Tests

There are also differences between DNA Prenatal Paternity Testing and traditional paternity tests in terms of when they can be carried out.

Timing for DNA Prenatal Paternity Testing

DNA Prenatal Paternity Testing can be conducted from the 10th week of pregnancy, allowing for early verification of paternity. This early timing is a significant advantage for couples seeking results in the early stages of pregnancy.

Timing for Traditional Paternity Testing

Traditional paternity testing, especially post-birth DNA testing, can only be done after delivery. Invasive prenatal tests like amniocentesis and CVS are typically performed between the 15th and 20th week of pregnancy, which is slightly later compared to DNA Prenatal Paternity Testing.

Conclusion

Both DNA Prenatal Paternity Testing and traditional paternity testing have unique advantages and challenges. DNA Prenatal Paternity Testing is non-invasive, highly accurate, and provides early results but is expensive and often not covered by insurance. Traditional paternity testing, while accurate, can involve risks if done invasively during pregnancy and can also be costly.

Choosing between these methods should be based on individual circumstances and needs. DNA Prenatal Paternity Testing is an excellent option for couples seeking safety and early results, particularly if avoiding miscarriage risk is a priority.

Ultimately, consulting with a physician or genetic counselor to choose the most appropriate testing method is crucial. Understanding the differences between DNA Prenatal Paternity Testing and traditional paternity testing, and considering their respective advantages and risks, will help ensure a more informed and comfortable decision.

Hiro Clinic’s DNA Prenatal Paternity Testing

Hiro Clinic’s DNA Prenatal Paternity Testing (NIPPT) is available at the industry’s lowest price at Hiro Clinic’s directly managed locations nationwide. Testing can be done from the 6th week of pregnancy onward, and the process is completed in a single visit, minimizing inconvenience. If a retest is necessary, it will be conducted free of charge, so you can rest assured. Additionally, tests are conducted at the Tokyo Sanitary Laboratory, which has over 50,000 cases of prenatal testing experience, ensuring reliable results. However, both partners are required to visit the clinic to ensure the most accurate test results. For more information, please check here and make your reservation or inquiry.

Supervisor of the article

---

Dr. Hiroshi Oka

Director of CAP Laboratory

Graduated from Keio University, Faculty of Medicine

Doctor of Medicine

Medical Doctor