Risk of cheating and submitting specimens during DNA testing.

親子鑑定 NIPPT DNA鑑定 ごまかす リスク

In DNA testing, fudging and submitting a different specimen is a very serious matter and is strictly prohibited ethically and legally. If an incorrect specimen is knowingly submitted, the following consequences and effects are possible

1.Loss of accuracy of appraisal results

DNA testing is scientifically very reliable in proving parent-child relationships and in criminal investigations. However, if a specimen is submitted falsely, the results will be false and not in accordance with the original purpose. This can cause serious problems, especially in the case of appraisals involving legal procedures.

2. Legal implications

  • Nullification of evidence in court: If the expert testimony is relevant to legal proceedings (e.g., custody disputes or inheritance issues), knowingly submitting an incorrect specimen may invalidate the evidence and lead to adverse consequences.
  • Legal Sanctions: If you are found to have obstructed expert testimony or provided false evidence, you may be subject to legal sanctions for perjury or fraud.

3. Possibility of unauthorized detection by the appraiser

Many laboratories have multiple verification processes in place for specimen identification.For example, in the case of paternity testing, inconsistencies in comparing the DNA profiles of the mother, father, and child may raise suspicion that an incorrect sample was submitted.Also, if the submitted sample shows unexpected results, a retest may be requested.

4. Reappraisal is required

If fraud is discovered, reappraisals may be required. If legal proceedings are involved, reappraisals can be an additional cost and time-consuming process, placing additional burdens on those involved.

5. Breakdown of trust

In domestic and legal relationships, DNA testing is used as important evidence.Deliberately falsifying a specimen and submitting it can undermine trust and cause problems and disputes between the parties involved.

Summary

Submitting fraudulent specimens in DNA testing is an extremely risky and severely punishable practice, both legally and ethically. It is important to submit the correct specimen and adhere to transparent procedures to ensure reliable results. When using an appraisal to resolve a legal matter or personal relationship, it is best to proceed through the process with integrity.

Supervisor of the article


Dr. Hiroshi Oka

Director of CAP Laboratory

Graduated from Keio University, Faculty of Medicine

Doctor of Medicine

Medical Doctor