Can prenatal paternity DNA testing be done from DNA on straws?

Although it is technically possible to carry out prenatal paternity DNA testing from DNA on straws, there are some limitations and considerations to take into account. These are explained in more detail below.

1. Quantity and quality of DNA

  • Amount of DNA: the amount of DNA collected from saliva and oral cells that adhere to the straw must be sufficient.Straws are in direct contact with the mouth and are likely to have more DNA on them than paper cups, but often in smaller quantities.
  • DNA quality: DNA on straws is sensitive to environmental influences and can be degraded by drying, heat and UV light. Degraded DNA is prone to fragmentation, which can affect the accuracy of the analysis.

2.The peculiarities of prenatal parentage testing

  • Comparison with maternal sample: prenatal paternity testing involves comparing the DNA of the foetus extracted from the mother’s blood with that of the potential father. If the DNA of the prospective father taken from the straw is of sufficient quantity and quality, it can be compared and tested.
  • Ensuring accuracy: a very high level of accuracy is required for identification. If DNA from straws is degraded or mixed with other DNA, it can be difficult to obtain accurate results.

3. Risk of contamination

  • Cross-contamination: there is a risk of DNA on the straw mixing with other DNA.Other DNA may adhere to the straw when it is used by more than one person or when the sample is stored or transported, and this may affect the results of the identification.

4. Legal and ethical aspects

  • Informed consent: it is essential to obtain appropriate consent (informed consent) from all parties before carrying out an appraisal. Legal and ethical procedures are particularly important as prenatal paternity testing is a sensitive issue.

Summary

It is possible to carry out prenatal paternity DNA testing from DNA on straws, but the following conditions are necessary for success

  • The ability to collect sufficient quantities of high-quality DNA from straws.
  • Prevent contamination of samples and obtain accurate results.
  • Strict controls and analyses should be in place to maintain a high level of accuracy in prenatal paternity testing.

Although technically feasible, the actual identification requires detailed consideration by an expert.Also, if DNA samples from straws are not sufficient, other sampling methods may need to be considered.

Supervisor of the article


Dr. Hiroshi Oka

Director of CAP Laboratory

Graduated from Keio University, Faculty of Medicine

Doctor of Medicine

Medical Doctor